Supreme Court Retracts Critique of Allahabad Judge Amid Backlash
The Supreme Court reversed its order criticizing Allahabad High Court's Justice Prashant Kumar. Following internal dissent, the apex court clarified its non-interference with the High Court's administrative powers, emphasizing judicial integrity. This move underscores high court autonomy while cautioning against blurring civil and criminal legal distinctions.
- Country:
- India
In a significant turn of events, the Supreme Court on Friday walked back on its previous order that criticized Allahabad High Court Judge Justice Prashant Kumar. The initial order had asked for the removal of Justice Kumar from the criminal roster over his involvement in permitting criminal proceedings in a civil money recovery dispute.
The controversial directive led to an internal outcry, with thirteen High Court judges rallying for a review of the Supreme Court's stance. This judicial solidarity prompted Chief Justice of India B.R. Gavai to reach out to Justice Pardiwala, urging reconsideration. Consequently, Justices Pardiwala and Mahadevan decided to retract the contentious paragraphs, reaffirming that their intent was not to disparage Justice Kumar.
The Supreme Court further underscored that the Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court retains complete administrative authority over judge rostering. This clarification seeks to maintain the dignity of the judiciary while cautioning against transforming civil disputes into criminal cases, a trend that has increasingly burdened India's legal system.
(With inputs from agencies.)
Google News