Supreme Court Upholds Karnataka's Decision in Dasara Inauguration Case

The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed an appeal challenging the Karnataka High Court's approval of the state government's decision to invite Booker Prize winner Banu Mushtaq to inaugurate the Dasara Mahotsav at Chamundeshwari temple in Mysuru. Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta highlighted India's secular ethos, emphasizing the state's inability to segregate based on religion.

The petitioner's counsel argued that allowing a non-Hindu to perform 'Agra Puja' inside the temple contravenes religious sentiments. Despite a plea for an urgent review, the bench maintained that public programs under state auspices cannot discriminate against any faith.

Previously, the Karnataka High Court had dismissed objections to Mushtaq's participation, reasoning that involvement in cross-faith festival celebrations does not breach constitutional rights. Historically, the festival has welcomed diverse dignitaries, and the inclusion of Banu Mushtaq is consistent with this precedent.

The appeal contended that Dasara inaugurations by non-Hindus dishonor traditional rituals and Agama Shastra, crucial to Hindu faith, potentially affecting the sanctity of the ceremony. However, both courts concluded that state-sponsored festivities should reflect India's commitment to secularism.